Corporal punishment for children and its link with violence in the world today.

I never thought I would write a blog about corporal punishment or how wrong it is. I mean reams, literally reams has been written about this. On how corporal punishment is just wrong. Very few facts about parenting are stated so simply and plainly as this one. Yet parenting when it comes to our boys, does not seem to be changing much.

This set me thinking. Is it because somewhere the wood is being lost due to the trees? Is the link to violence in our world being strongly linked to the way children are exposed to violence and the way we parent them?

Then this last week, watching the news as I ran on my treadmill, made me think about this plain and simple parenting fact once again.

Did any of you see the following news clips this last week?

  • Ukrainians raising Nazi slogans at a football match and kicking, punching, hitting Asian viewers, in a hate rage.
  • Russian parliament – opposition parties having fist fights in the House of Governance.

In a flash I could see how I lost my temper, as my child willfully pulled down platefuls of food from the table as she had not been given what she wanted, and raised my hand to whack her little bottom and winced. Yes actually winced in regret, remorse and face palm kind of shaking understanding of how much wrong I had done to our world, with that one action. Of not being able to control my own impatience which resulted in temper, of not being able to hear or see what my child was actually saying, of not being able to understand the consequences of my action – had I continued with it.

If there was one dissent that I had with my husband in the early years of our marriage and children, it was when I raised my hand on them. This deterred me more than anything else could have and for this I thank him today from the bottom of my heart. Even today I lose my temper (my personality I’m afraid – I have spent years and years and years trying to control it, but that is a chapter for another blog) and I feel that surge of violence, where I can see only destruction in front of me and I run to the bathroom and lock myself away and keep washing my face to cool down. So that I do not ever, raise my hand on my children, again.

Thus this is a topic I feel very strongly about.

So now, one question: “how many of us baby boomers did not get a whack or two from our parents growing up? I believe my husband never did 🙂 I got many. I got into fisticuffs often with my siblings. We indulged in unbridled raw anger and animal behavior growing up.  So now I look at the patterns and question myself, what was happening here. Are we perpetuating this cycle of violence?

Thus here is something to think about and stop that perpetuating cycle – especially for new parents.

Those above mentioned two events this past week just left me aghast. I watched these clips again and again on You Tube videos, with amazed horror of the sheer bestiality on display on my laptop screen. To be honest, there have been enough fist fights and scuffles in Parliaments across the world, including India, the UK and even America, between grown and ostensibly educated men. To say nothing of the violence and fisticuffs on a football field. However, this time upon watching these clips what struck me was the common theme of such happenings. Men of all classes and exposures – educated, professionals or hooligans were all alike when it came to such bestial behavior. It did not take a second for men of education and men of none to start fist fighting each other.

Made me think. How were these men brought up? What did they learn growing up? How come they cannot control their “animal” instincts. I must first apologize to animals here – as animals use brute strength to kill when they are hungry for food. Not for sport. Not due to lack of anger management skills. Not to make a point!

And which human being listens to any point, much less internalizes it, when it made by a fist in the area that hurts the most?

Yet we mothers do not learn. Mind boggling really. Yes you read right, I blame their mothers, those uncouth slur on mankind live pieces of flesh and bones I watched this week, attempting to use brute physical power to make a point. I am sure that either their mothers and / or their fathers used violence against them or they were exposed to some sort of violence growing up.

Just think about it for a minute, if you child does something wrong and usually does not listen to you, you slap or whack the child, what is the message you are giving to the child. That it is okay to use physical violence when the other person has done something you perceive to be wrong and does not listen to you! And thus a parent perpetuates the cycle of physical violence in this world. Just look at the underworld and the light will finally shine on you. The underworld anywhere – Latin America, India, Mexico, USA, Italy. Who are those that tend towards crime. I have not done or checked out with research, but I can bet you they are mostly the children who are used to physical violence at home.

My daughter plays football, my son does not. Has anybody ever seen a female football team playing the game? I urge all you new mothers and fathers of sons to do this. I vouch that when the going gets tough in the game, females play using technique, skill and strategy. Males in similar situations use brute force! This is not corrected when boys start playing football at two years old. In fact, this is encouraged. Parents feel secretly proud if their boy tackles the opponent boy and wrestles the ball away. Coaches do not call foul. If a child gets hurt, he is pulled out of the game and the game goes on. There is no penalty for brute force. Till it is brutal. Why?

Just a simple question – why? Why is skill, strategy and team work not celebrated? Why is brute force acceptable? Why is brute force understood as ‘part of the game’?

One more question: how many of us mothers of sons have purchased guns, pistols, swords, bows and arrows, toy soldiers and tanks and other even more 21st Century weaponry as toys for our boys without even thinking about it? How many of us mothers of boys have sat back and enjoyed our son physically spar with his friend, all in play, as his father and mother looked fondly on?

The point I am making is that to stop the violence that wracks our world, from grown and ostensibly educated men in the government house to wars on a battle field, we have to stop our sons from using their fists when the going gets tough.

How to do this. Here are some simple steps I have learned as I was “growing up” nurturing my own children:

  1. It is okay for your son to cry, even at 16 years old. Or even at 18. Or your husband too to cry when he is emotional. It is important to communicate this to them. Clearly and ambiguously. Do restrain from placating with words like “big boys do not cry” or “come on stop crying now and be a man” and such like asinine stuff.
  2. Never ever (no matter what the provocation) raise your hand on your children – boy or girl.
  3. When you see your boy using physical force to make a point with his siblings, friends, co-students, stop it at once. Liken such behavior as being inferior to a dumb animal behavior even.
  4. Speak about emotions with your son, on love, hate, jealousy, sadness, pain, joy, greed and sensitivity. Let your boy/s understand that an emotional quotient of any human is what makes for success or not.
  5. When you see your boy getting emotional (quivering lip, watery eyes, strained body, stiff posture are just a few physically visible signs), cradle him in your lap and let him cry, let him vent.
  6. Do not buy weapon toys for your boys. Take a maybe “dramatic” stance (according to some) against it. It will be worth it when you see your boy using his brain more than brawn in play. Board games like Risk teach strategy in war and kids are curious about wars, so this is one way of having a communication about war and its implications.
  7. If you see your son play with a doll, don’t snatch it away and behave like blasphemy has been committed and that your son may turn gay! Seriously, a son being gay or not has nothing to do with playing with dolls as a child.
  8. Never, ever ever tolerate your boy getting into fisticuffs with anyone.

Okay here I want to qualify point number 8 with a story. When the whole physical violence thing dawned on me, my son was still just 7 years old. I remember having many conversations with him about not ever resorting to physical violence etc (as I have said above), till one day he asked me “so if someone is beating me up, I should just get beaten? Is this what you are saying?” I said “no never tolerate physical violence directed at you or at anyone else.” After having said this, all those stories that I have heard flashed into my mind about good men going to help women / other men against whom violence is being played out unfairly and  get hurt badly at the least or lose their life at worst. I had to think about this one. After a few days I sat him down and said “if there is physical violence being used against you, you have to stop it. So do whatever it takes. However, remember that you must never incite physical violence nor encourage it. When you see physical violence happening and men becoming worse than animals, I want you to walk away. Only stop it, if there is no other option available.”

I am convinced that if we mothers understand what is happening around us in our world today is directly related to the way we bring up our boys, then maybe our world will reflect the superiority of our species more. Right now it reflects more about how pernicious our species is!


6 thoughts on “Corporal punishment for children and its link with violence in the world today.

  1. You certainly are a gutsy lady taking on a very contentious subject, and one that is laden with emotion. I do think however, that it a little dangerous to use conjecture when outlining your stance– there is no way that we one can surmise that the thugs were victims of parental violence – your words “ I am absolutely sure that their mothers and their fathers used violence against them” . cannot be taken as anything but a subjective opinion, and as such, are unfortunately invalid in this argument. I totally agree with you that raising a hand in anger to a child is never justified however I personally feel that there is a clear distinction between violence and corporal punishment. Violence does indeed perpetuate violence and, as such any violence, be it from parents, other individuals, or state institutions, can never be tolerated. This is a whole other debate – which by definition must include the innate sinfulness and rottenness of mankind which leads us to behave in such abhorrent ways. Corporal punishment on the other hand, should be devoid of emotion – my personal belief is that it is a last resort (note, last resort) for a serious infraction of rules or norms. I believe that other types of punishment should be explored first, however, there is a time and a place when a firm paddle on the backside is warranted. It should never be a spontaneous knee-jerk reaction to a minor infraction but should be undertaken after careful consideration and with an attitude of love. I mean this sincerely. The child needs to fully understand the reason for the paddle, and also needs to express repentance for his/her actions, and most importantly, to then know that they have received the punishment they deserve – this done, they are then in a sense, “free” of any guilt. I could wax lyrical on this subject for reams, but would like to leave you with a question – do you feel that corporal punishment (not violence) is ever justified? And what if we extend the debate to crimes such as adult sexual abuse of children – what ought our response to be? Is a noose around the neck of a child rapist justifiable?

    • Hi Tracey, nice to see that you are taking the time to read my blog.
      As regards me being gutsy, did you ever doubt it? 🙂 My stance is, I am not the last word, I am sharing my experiences and learning from it. Never share never learn is what I think.
      Your criticism may be valid (as I mention in my piece that I have not got any research on ALL thugs having being subject to violence at home) but I do say that instinctively I feel that this must be the case FOR MOST THUGS. Why do I have this instinct? Mainly because of the way I grew up. I saw children and how they lived and who later on went to become thugs.
      On your point about a good paddle may be justified, I disagree Tracey. Physical reprimand or corporal punishment, to my mind, should never ever be required. Can never be justified. If a child has done wrong, you cannot right it by doing another wrong. And using one’s physical ‘power’ over one who is dependent on one, never gets any parent buy in. There is always another way. As parents we need to think about it and find that other way. When I was growing up, parents went about proudly stating “spare the rod, spoil the child”. Today I think it should be “spare the rod and save the adult.”

      On child sexual abuse, I do not think we can extend this debate to this kind of crime. My stance on corporal punishment is, if you do not use it but use other means then you will not have a deviant / criminal minded adult in the making. Thus on child sexual abuse, I just have one stance – immediate annihilation of such monsters from our world. To my mind, there is no way they can be treated to become better.

  2. Ah Anu, we will need to agree to differ on this one….I haven’t paddled my children in years, however there have been times when it has been the last resort – picture 3 year old twins with a penchant for putting their fingers into the wonderfully unsafe Vietnamese electrical sockets (with no socket guards to be found in the country at that time!) – I tried reasoning with them, tried getting them to understand the implications of their actions and eventually, took out a wooden spoon (barbaric, I can hear you shout 🙂 ) and gave them a firm smack on the behind. Firm enough to hurt, not firm enough to leave any type of mark. They then knew that the next time they tried their little trick – their amply padded backsides were going to hurt! Worked a treat as I never had to paddle them for this again….and I sincerely believe it did them no enduring harm….to my mind, it probably saved their lives! Having said this, I certainly am not critical of you as a mother – your children are living proof of the fabulous job you have done!! I constantly point out this or that which your stunning daughter has done/achieved and hold her as a shining example to my daughter 🙂 – perhaps at the end of the day it is not our parenting style which defines who our children will become but rather our unconditional love and belief in them as the exceptional individuals that they each are, our respect for the world we live in and the appreciation for the diversity of mankind, which then helps them become the best that they can be xx

    • My dear Tracey, thank you for those complements. And before I go any further, I would like to point out that LIKE YOU, I whacked a buttock, and shamefacedly admit it. I did it a few times for my son mainly, as by the time my daughter came, I did find another way. There is absolutely no value judgement on any mother in my piece. Maybe I should write a blog on a disclaimer 🙂 in that regard. I too learned from making that mistake first myself. I know from first hand experience (as do you) that mothering is very very hard, but empowering one’s children to make the right choices for themselves the hardest job ever. Yet mothers like me want to do it like a juggling act, being using our professional skills at work and then running home to “mother”. Gosh I am not surprised that I whacked my child!

      One last thing I want to say here is that as a child I got many a whack and for this I do not love my mother less nor did it ruin me. But I know that I am much faster on the whacking scale that my husband who was never whacked. Thus I did not want to perpetuate the cycle. Thus absolutely agree that all loving whacks do not a criminal make. However, it is still keeping that violence alive in our DNA. And this is what I am espousing to change. Additionally, as I have noted your point that all thugs may not have suffered parental violence, thus I have changed that to reflect that there must have been great exposure to physical violence as they were growing up – for them to be the way they are.

  3. In light of the Judge Adams video,

    We often hear from those who fight to uphold this practice for those under the age of 18 (even to the blaming of the social maladies of the day on a supposed “lack” of it), but we rarely, if ever, find advocates for the return of corporal punishment to the general adult community, college campuses, inmate population, or military. Why is that?

    Ask ten unyielding proponents of child/adolescent/teenage-only “spanking” about the “right” way to do it, and what would be abusive, indecent, or obscene, and you will get ten different answers.

    These proponents should consider making their own video-recording of the “right way” to do it.

    Visit Parents and Teachers Against Violence in Education to learn more.

  4. Children should have a right to their bodies, and the right to say “No!”

    Currently in the U.S.:

    When an adult does it to another adult, its sexual battery:

    When children do it to adults, its a “deviant sexual prank”:

    When an adult does it to a person under the age of 18, its “good discipline”.

    Research/recommended reading:

    Spanking Can Make Children More Aggressive Later

    Spanking Kids Increases Risk of Sexual Problems

    Use of Spanking for 3-Year-Old Children and Associated Intimate Partner Aggression or Violence

    Spanking Children Can Lower IQ

    Plain Talk About Spanking
    by Jordan Riak

    The Sexual Dangers of Spanking Children
    by Tom Johnson

    “Spanking” can be intentional or unintentional sexual abuse

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s